Customer experience is the total impression a customer forms across every interaction with an institution, from the first advertisement to the last complaint. For an institution supervised by Indonesia's Otoritas Jasa Keuangan (OJK), seven points on that journey are already regulated: POJK Nomor 22 Tahun 2023, promulgated on 22 December 2023, requires written policies from product design through complaint handling (Article 8) and makes the board of directors answerable for compliance (Article 90). Between 1 January and 14 September 2026 OJK received 82,092 consumer complaints, 26,091 of them about banks.
This piece is for heads of digital and CIOs at banks, insurers, securities firms and financing companies operating in Indonesia, including regional teams who run an Indonesian entity from Singapore or Kuala Lumpur. It covers three things: which parts of customer experience are already obligations, who owns them inside the institution, and what the five measures most often put in front of a board can and can't prove. The regulations cited are published in Indonesian. Translations are ours, and article numbers follow the original "Pasal" numbering so your compliance team can check each one.
Our view, stated up front: at a supervised institution, customer experience is a governance matter before it's a software one. A CRM records interactions. It doesn't write the Article 8 policies, and it isn't what the directors answer for.
Customer experience at an Indonesian financial institution: seven regulated points
The words "customer experience" and "satisfaction" don't appear as obligations in POJK 22/2023. What the regulation contains is a definition of market conduct supervision, in Article 1 point 20:
Pengawasan Perilaku PUJK (Market Conduct) adalah pengawasan terhadap perilaku PUJK dalam mendesain, menyediakan dan menyampaikan informasi, menawarkan, menyusun perjanjian, memberikan pelayanan atas penggunaan produk dan/atau layanan, serta penanganan Pengaduan dan penyelesaian Sengketa dalam upaya mewujudkan Pelindungan Konsumen.
In our translation: market conduct supervision is supervision of how a financial services provider (PUJK, Pelaku Usaha Jasa Keuangan) designs, provides and conveys information, offers, drafts agreements, delivers service on the use of products and services, and handles complaints and resolves disputes.
Read the order: design, information, offer, agreement, service, complaint. That's a customer journey map, and the regulator wrote it. The reading is ours, not OJK's wording. Article 8 paragraphs (1) and (2) then require "kebijakan dan prosedur tertulis Pelindungan Konsumen" (written consumer protection policies and procedures) for seven activities:
- design of products and/or services;
- provision of information;
- delivery of information;
- marketing;
- drafting of agreements;
- service on the use of products and/or services;
- complaint handling and dispute resolution.
Each item has a matching screen in the app: the product page, the summary information sheet, the offer notification, the terms and conditions screen, the help menu, the complaint form. A digital team designing those screens is working on a supervised object whether or not it uses that name. The rule applies to commercial banks, rural banks (BPR), securities firms, insurers, financing companies and the other providers listed in Article 2.
Who owns customer experience under POJK 22/2023
Article 88 paragraph (1) says "PUJK wajib memiliki fungsi atau unit untuk pelaksanaan ketentuan Pelindungan Konsumen dan masyarakat": a provider must have a function or unit that implements the consumer protection rules. Article 90 paragraph (1) says "Direksi wajib bertanggung jawab atas kepatuhan pelaksanaan ketentuan Peraturan Otoritas Jasa Keuangan ini": the board of directors must be responsible for compliance with the regulation.
Indonesian companies have a two-tier board, and the board of commissioners (Dewan Komisaris) must oversee that responsibility (Article 90 paragraph 2). The directors must appoint one of their own number, or an officer one level below at head office, who reports directly to them (Article 90 paragraphs 3 and 4). The unit reports on implementation and recommends improvements to the directors (Article 89 letter d). It may be combined with another function, but the elucidation of Article 88 paragraph (5) bars marketing staff from handling complaints that involve themselves. The fine for breaching Article 88 is capped at Rp15 billion (Article 88 paragraph 12), and sanctions under Article 90 paragraph (6) can fall on the provider, its directors and/or its commissioners, up to removal from office.
Banks that operate payment systems have a second layer. Peraturan Bank Indonesia Nomor 6 Tahun 2026, issued 24 June 2026, revokes PBI 3/2023 (Article 126) and states "Penyelenggara wajib memiliki unit khusus Pelindungan Konsumen": an operator must have a dedicated consumer protection unit (Article 55 paragraph 1).
So the head of digital owns the design of the experience, while responsibility for compliance sits with the directors and flows through the consumer protection unit. A CX number that never reaches that unit never enters the report to the board.
Five customer experience metrics and the limit of each
POJK 22/2023 doesn't require NPS, CSAT or any satisfaction survey. What it requires you to count is complaints. The other four measures are management's choice, and each one measures a different sample.
| Metric | Formula and scale | What it shows | What it does not show | Owner we suggest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net Promoter Score (NPS) | Scale 0–10. Percentage of promoters (9–10) minus percentage of detractors (0–6). Scores of 7–8 are passive. | Intent to recommend among survey respondents | The cause of the score, and customers who did not answer | Head of digital |
| CSAT | No single formula: a mean score, or the percentage of respondents choosing the top values | Satisfaction with one interaction that has just happened | Comparison between institutions, unless formula and scale are identical | Channel owner (app, branch, contact centre) |
| Customer Effort Score (CES) | One question on how much effort the customer spent getting the task done | Friction in one flow | Whether that friction is required by a rule | Product owner of that flow |
| App store rating | Scale 1–5, one number for the whole app | Public sentiment among users who rate | Which flow is failing; users who never rate | Head of digital with IT |
| Complaint count | A mandatory count: every complaint received, recorded and documented (Article 70 paragraph 1) | Failures serious enough that the customer reported them | Customers who gave up without reporting | Consumer protection unit (Article 88) |
The last column is our suggestion. Only the complaints row has a basis in the regulation.
NPS: the scale is 0–10, and the claim has been tested
The definition above follows Bain & Company, one of the trademark's owners. There's one question: how likely are you to recommend us to a friend or colleague. Detractors start at 0, not 1.
Keiningham, Cooil, Andreassen and Aksoy tested the NPS claim against longitudinal data from 21 firms and more than 15,500 interviews in the Norwegian Customer Satisfaction Barometer. The abstract of that study, published in the Journal of Marketing 71(3), July 2007, reports that they failed to replicate the claimed "clear superiority" of NPS over other measures. NPS is still useful as an internal trend. As the only number in a board report, it stands on weak ground.
CSAT is two different numbers
A mean score of 4.2 out of 5 and "84% of respondents chose 4 or 5" can come from the same data, and both get called CSAT (those two figures are an illustration, not data). Before comparing CSAT with a vendor, a subsidiary, a parent group's regional figure or last period, ask for the formula, the scale, the number of respondents and the survey channel.
We found no NPS or CSAT benchmark for Indonesian banking from a primary source, so we print none. CES is usually traced to Dixon, Freeman and Toman, "Stop Trying to Delight Your Customers" (Harvard Business Review, July–August 2010); the article is paywalled and we don't quote from it.
Complaints: the only mandatory metric, and narrow by design
An oral complaint must be resolved within 5 working days (Article 74 paragraph 1). A written complaint gets 10 working days from complete documents, extendable by another 10 (Article 75 paragraphs 1 and 2). The report goes to OJK every semester, no later than the 10th of the following month (Article 79). The elucidation of Article 89 letter b even gives the example "menetapkan target kinerja Layanan Pengaduan", setting performance targets for the complaint service.
The limit is in the definition. Article 1 point 7 defines a complaint indicating a dispute as an expression of dissatisfaction "yang disebabkan oleh adanya kerugian dan/atau potensi kerugian materi": caused by material loss or potential material loss. A prospect who abandons account opening halfway without losing a single rupiah is outside that category. The complaint count measures serious failure. Day-to-day friction escapes it.
Play Store ratings of 13 Indonesian banking apps, 12 October 2026
We pulled the ratings of 13 mobile banking apps on 12 October 2026 at 03:33 UTC (10:33 Jakarta time). They range from 2.53 to 4.83 on a 5-point scale. The method: a curl request with a desktop Chrome user agent to each app's Play Store page with the parameters hl=id&gl=ID, reading ratingValue and ratingCount from the page's JSON-LD. These are the figures the Indonesian storefront serves; another country's storefront may show different ones. The pull and the drafting of this article were AI-assisted, and you can repeat the pull yourself the same way.
| App | Rating | Number of ratings |
|---|---|---|
| Permata ME | 2.53 | 145,319 |
| Livin' by Mandiri | 2.76 | 775,130 |
| Jenius | 3.28 | 203,977 |
| OCBC mobile Indonesia | 3.68 | 50,948 |
| BCA mobile | 3.99 | 1,384,798 |
| myBCA | 4.00 | 106,734 |
| bale by BTN | 4.09 | 35,063 |
| BNI Mobile Banking | 4.43 | 1,085,403 |
| OCTO by CIMB Niaga | 4.53 | 360,032 |
| BRImo | 4.60 | 2,259,544 |
| Bank Jago | 4.72 | 283,850 |
| neobank BNC | 4.76 | 370,747 |
| wondr by BNI | 4.83 | 1,413,465 |
This is a dated snapshot. It isn't a quality ranking or a list of the largest banks, and we didn't order it by assets. Two apps from the same bank can sit 0.40 points apart (BNI Mobile Banking at 4.43, wondr by BNI at 4.83). Against our own pull on 10 October 2026, three figures moved by 0.01 (Jenius, OCTO, myBCA) and the rest of those we measured on both dates didn't change. A number that barely moves in two days is too slow to judge a weekly release.
Next to it: 26,091 banking complaints to OJK
According to OJK press release SP 185/OJK/DKPU/X/2026 dated 5 October 2026, from 1 January to 14 September 2026 OJK received 527,389 service requests through its consumer protection portal, Aplikasi Portal Pelindungan Konsumen (APPK), including 82,092 complaints: 36,435 about financial technology, 26,091 about banking, 16,758 about financing companies, 1,446 about insurance and 1,362 about capital markets and other non-bank financial industries.
| OJK press release | Data to | Total complaints | Banking | Banking share (our calculation) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SP 147/DKPU/OJK/VIII/2026, 4 August 2026 | 13 July 2026 | 57,366 | 18,578 | 32.4% |
| SP 166/OJK/DKPU/IX/2026, 7 September 2026 | 14 August 2026 | 70,523 | 22,668 | 32.1% |
| SP 185/OJK/DKPU/X/2026, 5 October 2026 | 14 September 2026 | 82,092 | 26,091 | 31.8% |
Over those 257 days that's 101.5 banking complaints a day, and complaints are 15.6% of all service requests. These are complaints that reached OJK through APPK, not the complaints each institution received directly.
No data links app ratings to complaint counts causally, and we don't claim it. The two sit side by side because they capture different populations: people who rate and people who report. The financial consequence is recorded in the same press release: 52 fines imposed on 44 providers between 1 January and 13 September 2026, and 157 providers compensating consumers for losses worth Rp82.96 billion.
The literacy–inclusion gap as a design constraint
SNLIK 2026, the national survey of financial literacy and inclusion (joint press release by OJK, the deposit insurer LPS and the statistics agency BPS, SP 152/OJK/DKPU/VIII/2026, 11 August 2026), records a financial literacy index of 69.57% and an inclusion index of 93.61% from 75,000 respondents aged 15–79. The gap is 24.04 points. In the 51–79 age group, literacy is 60.01% and inclusion 90.51%: a gap of 30.50 points. The subtraction is ours. Inclusion is measured by use, so the figure describes people who already hold a financial product and are measurably less equipped to understand it.
For anyone designing a flow, that's a hard constraint, and it's the one a design system imported from a regional head office is most likely to miss. A product summary screen that passes testing with head-office staff in their thirties in Jakarta won't necessarily be readable to a 60-year-old customer in a rural district; the literacy index is 64.42% in rural areas against 72.54% in cities. A persona set that leaves out the group with the widest gap ignores the customers most likely to misunderstand, and then to complain. How to put those customers in front of a flow before launch, and what to record when you do, is in our guide to usability testing for banks before go-live.
Mandatory friction: a securities account opening example
Almost everything written about CX treats friction as the enemy. On a supervised channel some friction is an obligation: identity verification, disclosure before consent, confirmation. The design work is to order those mandatory steps and make them clear. Removing them isn't an option.
An example from our own work: the online registration system for CGS International. The case study titles the project's challenge "Balancing Regulation with Usability", and its first item reads "Ensuring all platform features adhere to financial laws and guidelines without compromising functionality". The published scope: a web form with OCR, video call and self-verification, and connections to banks, CGS-CIMB, the central securities depository KSEI and the civil registry DUKCAPIL.
The case study carries no outcome figure such as a registration completion rate, and we claim none here. What we can say is that the project's challenge was framed as regulation and usability together, in one line. The mapping of which steps the law requires and which are product choices is in our article on the six steps of KYC verification in Indonesia.
What the head of digital and compliance need to decide
- Merge the dashboard. NPS, CSAT, app store rating and complaints go on one page to the consumer protection unit, because under Article 89 letter d that unit is the one reporting to the directors.
- Write the denominator of every number. Formula, scale, respondent count, channel and date. A CX figure without a denominator can't be defended in front of the board of commissioners.
- Map the seven Article 8 activities to screens. Every screen has a business owner and a compliance reviewer before release.
- Use the complaint deadlines as product SLAs. 5 working days for oral complaints, 10 + 10 for written ones, the semester report by the 10th, the annual self-assessment by 30 September (Article 85 paragraph 2).
- Put customers aged 51–79 into research. The group with a 30.50-point literacy–inclusion gap can't be absent from the sample.
For compliance, one thing to guard: don't let the sentence "OJK requires NPS" into an internal document, a vendor proposal or a regional group standard. The text of POJK 22/2023 doesn't contain it. What it requires is a function, written policies, complaint records and reporting. If your institution is redesigning a flow that touches those seven activities, WEBARQ's UX research and UX design team and our mobile app development team can talk through the scope with you.








